Let’s get one thing straight: when it comes to Taylor Swift, the woman can’t take a step without the world holding up a magnifying glass to her love life. Breakups, makeups, and everything in between — Taylor’s love life is basically an open book (or, more accurately, an open album). While the world’s been busy analysing her exes, accusing them of cheating, manipulating, and generally being messed up, there’s one question that we need to ask: Is Taylor Swift the one doing the cheating? Yep, you heard that right.

She’s always the heartbroken one, right? The sweet, doe-eyed girl whose boyfriends broke her heart. But wait — what if Taylor’s lyrics aren’t just about being betrayed?

What if she’s actually admitting to some morally iffy behaviour herself? Cue the gasp. Over the years, two specific scandals have sparked major rumours that Taylor might’ve crossed some lines herself: the whole Calvin Harris and Tom Hiddleston drama and, more recently, the Joe Alwyn and Matty Healy mess. So, are Taylor’s lyrics just a beautifully woven web of fiction… or is she singing about her own messy reality?

Let’s break it down. Spoiler alert: we’re diving into her own songs for the clues. So, buckle up. You might just rethink who the "bad guy" is in her love stories.

Image Credit: sjdavidl from Wikimedia Commons

Calvin Harris, Tom Hiddleston, and the Quickest Rebound Ever

Let’s go back to 2016, when Taylor was dating Calvin Harris, and the whole world was obsessed with their relationship. Everything seemed fine. Picture-perfect, really.

But then, just as quickly as it started, it ended. In May 2016, boom, they were done. The breakup seemed amicable enough at first, but then — and I mean then — the world watched in horror (or maybe, just fascination?) as Taylor moved on, like, instantly.

Less than two weeks after the breakup, Taylor was already hanging out with Tom Hiddleston on beaches, at parties, and basically in every corner of the tabloids. We’re talking about a “whirlwind romance” that lasted for about five minutes. But here’s the kicker: the timeline?

It didn’t add up. Was Taylor already emotionally involved with Tom before she broke up with Calvin? Was she secretly texting him during her relationship with Calvin? The questions were endless, and the rumours? Spicy.

So, while Taylor and Calvin played it cool in public, their breakup sure seemed like one of those where the “other person” was already in the picture, but no one wanted to admit it. We may never know if she actually cheated, but the timing sure didn’t help her case. Some fans even speculated that Taylor was emotionally checked out of her relationship with Calvin, which could explain the swift rebound. But hey, a girl has to live, right?

Image Credit: Ronald Woan from Wikimedia Commons

Take the Quiz: Choose Your Fall Flicks and Find Out If Your Halloween Fit Is ABBA Glam or Fleetwood Mac Magic!

Fall is the best time to snuggle up with a great movie, but your choices say more about you than you think! Take this quiz to see if your autumn mo...

Joe Alwyn, Matty Healy, and the Most Awkward Love Triangle Ever

In April 2023, the world stopped for Swifties. The news finally arrived that Taylor and Joe Alwyn, her boyfriend of six years, had broken up. It was shocking and confusing for the public, but fans did not have to wait to see Taylor's next relationship after the breakup.

Enter: Matty Healy, lead singer of The 1975. Fans were quick to connect the dots, and rumors started flying that Taylor and Matty were more than just friendly collaborators. In fact, some suggested that Matty was the reason behind her breakup with Joe.

Here’s where it gets really juicy: just weeks after her breakup with Joe, Taylor and Matty started popping up in the same circles. Whether it was at music events or during random hangouts, people started asking, “Did Taylor and Matty hook up? Did she emotionally cheat on Joe with him?” Now, we don’t have any concrete proof (because, obviously), but when the rumors hit, things got complicated.

Did Taylor cheat emotionally? Or was it just a case of two people spending time together and the press blowing everything out of proportion? The timing alone raised eyebrows.

But wait — here’s where it gets even more intriguing. Taylor, being the lyrical genius that she is, might’ve given us a clue in one of her songs. Have you heard “Guilty as Sin” from The Tortured Poets Department? Yeah, fans have been going wild over this one, and it’s not hard to see why.

Image Credit: Ronald Woan from Wikimedia Commons

“Guilty as Sin” — A Confession of Cheating, or Just a Bad Boy Fantasy?

Alright, let’s talk about “Guilty as Sin”. The title alone is basically a confession. Like, if someone says, “I’m guilty as sin,” they’re putting their hand on their heart and going, “Yep, I did it.” Now, the song doesn’t outright say, “I cheated on Joe with Matty,” but the lyrics sure as [censored] leave room for interpretation.

“I keep these longings locked; In lowercase, inside a vault...

These fatal fantasies give way to laboured breath

Taking all of me, we've already done it in my head.”

The lyrics convey emotional infidelity — the kind where someone is emotionally or mentally involved with someone else, even if the physical boundaries aren’t crossed. It’s like fantasizing about someone else while you're with someone — it’s not real, but it feels real in your mind. And that mental space becomes just as consuming, if not more, than physical actions.

There’s also a layer of guilt in this, the sense that she knows these thoughts are dangerous or forbidden. She’s not physically acting on them, but mentally, she’s already there.

Image Credit: Vixy13 from Wikimedia Commons

But here’s the thing: emotional cheating is still cheating. And the lyrics, when paired with the timeline of her post-Joe relationship, seem to scream, “I might have crossed a line.” We don’t know if she literally cheated, but the song definitely captures the feeling of being tangled in something you know you shouldn’t be, and kind of liking it. (That’s called emotional infidelity, my friends.)

So, what is Taylor admitting here? Is this her confession about Matty? Maybe. Or maybe it’s just a creative take on the idea of doing something bad, but enjoying the rush of it anyway. Either way, it's a heck of a song, and it leaves us asking, "Is she guilty or just misunderstood?"

Image Credit: Paolo V from Wikimedia Commons

What Does This All Mean?

Now, let’s back up and look at the bigger picture. Is Taylor Swift a cheater? The truth is, we can’t really know for sure. She’s not out here waving a flag that says “I cheated” (obviously), but the timing of these two major relationship shifts — Calvin Harris to Tom Hiddleston, and Joe Alwyn to Matty Healy — makes it hard to ignore that there might have been some emotional entanglements before the official breakups.

In both cases, Taylor’s lyrics hint at guilt, betrayal, and maybe a little moral ambiguity. She’s not shy about writing songs that explore the messier parts of relationships. Whether it's the thrill of an illicit connection or the regret of emotional straying, Taylor has been known to turn her personal experiences into catchy, haunting anthems that make us all wonder: “Was she really the one being cheated on... or was she doing the cheating?”

Image Credit: Sally-Marie Böhm from Wikimedia Commons

Ultimately, Taylor is a master at creating layers in her music, and whether she’s confessing her own flaws or just crafting stories to entertain, we’re all here for it. And until she decides to actually spill the tea on her relationships, we’ll just keep playing the guessing game. After all, that’s the Swiftie way.

And who knows? Maybe the next album will finally give us some answers. Or, maybe it’ll just leave us with more questions. Either way, we’re all guilty as sin for trying to decode it all.